
BEAT: Four Musical Heroes, One Extraordinary Night
Belew, Bozzio, Levin and Vai make King Crimson's music their own — despite a room that seemed determined to get in the way.
There are concerts you attend because you like the music.
There are concerts you attend because you've followed the musicians for years.
And then there are nights when four musicians you've admired for much of your life walk onto the same stage, and you find yourself wondering which one you're supposed to watch.
Sunday night at The Theatre at Great Canadian Casino Resort Toronto, in Etobicoke, was one of those nights.
Adrian Belew. Terry Bozzio. Tony Levin. Steve Vai.
I've listed them alphabetically because, frankly, I can't bring myself to rank them. At various points in my life, I've had some degree of hero worship for every one of these guys.
And there they were.
Together.
Playing King Crimson.
Holy shit.
Making the Music Their OwnBEAT celebrates King Crimson's extraordinary 1980s catalogue, particularly the albums Discipline, Beat and Three of a Perfect Pair, with some material from the band's later years finding its way into the repertoire.
But this isn't a tribute band trying to reproduce the original recordings note for note.
And thank goodness for that.
The melodies, lyrics, rhythms and essential arrangements remain recognizable, but the musicians aren't afraid to reinterpret them. There were improvised solos, altered passages, new textures and plenty of what I can only describe as Vai-isms.
The music was unmistakably King Crimson.
But it was also unmistakably BEAT.
They opened with “Dinosaur,” reaching into King Crimson's 1990s catalogue rather than beginning with the expected 1980s material.
And Adrian Belew can still sing.
I don't mean that as some backhanded compliment about a veteran musician managing to get through his old songs. His voice sounded strong, and he was still hitting those notes.
Then there was his guitar playing.
Watching Belew coax those strange, almost animal-like sounds out of his guitars was a reminder of just how distinctive a guitarist he is. Volume swells, whammy-bar manipulation, bends and effects turned the instrument into something that frequently sounded like anything but a guitar.
I've spent decades listening to Belew make those sounds.
Watching him do it right in front of me is another matter entirely.
One of the night's most remarkable performances came during “Neal and Jack and Me.”
The rhythmic interplay among Belew, Levin and Vai across the front of the stage was astonishing. Their parts interlocked with extraordinary precision, particularly when the rhythms began shifting against one another.
And somehow they made it look natural.
Tony Levin was doing what Tony Levin does.
Which is to say, things that would keep most bass players occupied for several lifetimes.
Throughout the evening, Levin moved between bass guitar, a bodyless electric upright bass and, most frequently, his Chapman Stick.
Watching him work the Stick was remarkable. His left hand would lay down the bass lines while his right played elaborate melodic figures, sometimes making it seem as though two musicians were sharing the same instrument.
Both parts had their own place in the arrangement, and somehow he made the whole business look almost effortless.
Then there were the Funk Fingers.
When Levin switched to bass guitar and brought out those little drumstick-like attachments on his fingers, the resulting sound was enormous. A wonderfully percussive attack that gave the bass an entirely different character.
Levin doesn't need to dominate the stage to command your attention.
Sometimes all he has to do is play a few notes.
“Sartori in Tangier” was another highlight, with Belew and Vai producing an astonishing assortment of sounds from their instruments, pushing familiar musical ideas through two very different guitar personalities.
The Impossible AssignmentI've admired Steve Vai for decades, but I was particularly interested in how he'd approach Robert Fripp's guitar parts.
Fripp's playing is so distinctive, and so integral to King Crimson's sound, that replacing him would seem an almost impossible assignment.
Fortunately, Vai doesn't appear particularly interested in pretending to be Robert Fripp.
He can play those demanding, interlocking parts with astonishing precision, but he also brings his own musical personality to them.
His dynamics were particularly impressive Sunday night, moving from delicate, restrained passages into something considerably more aggressive without making the transition feel forced.
Throughout the evening, little Vai-isms kept appearing.
A bend here. An unexpected flourish there. A phrase that took a familiar passage somewhere slightly different.
But during “Frame by Frame,” those Vai-isms took on a life of their own.
He took Fripp's meticulously constructed guitar figures and pushed them into entirely new territory, playing against Belew's stabbing chords, guitar noises and dive bombs, while preserving the tightly syncopated, interlocking guitar passages that lead into the vocals.
It was still unmistakably “Frame by Frame.”
But certainly not a note-for-note recreation.
And then there was “The Sheltering Sky.”
The piece provided an opportunity for Vai to stretch out, with Levin moving toward the back of the stage and Vai edging closer to centre.
Initially, I wasn't quite as taken with this year's performance as I'd been with last year's. Vai had impressed me more elsewhere during the evening, and this particular showcase wasn't quite reaching the same heights.
Then Belew took a beautifully atmospheric, effects-laden solo before leaving the stage, and Vai returned to the forefront.
And proceeded to make me reconsider that assessment.
Completely.
What followed was a remarkable display of guitar pyrotechnics. Vai was waving the instrument around, manipulating feedback with the whammy bar, at times holding the guitar over his head or behind his back.
It was pure showmanship, but there was nothing random about it. He knew exactly where he wanted the pitch of that feedback to go, shaping it into something musical even while doing things that looked almost ridiculous.
Plenty of guitarists can put on a show.
Steve Vai has the chops to make the show part of the music.
It was astounding.
Watch Steve Vai's solo during “The Sheltering Sky” — video by Virginia Storey, shared with permission.
A Room That Didn't HelpUnfortunately, not everything about the evening was extraordinary.
The Theatre at Great Canadian Casino Resort Toronto is an enormous square room with an absurdly high ceiling and vast amounts of open space around its upper reaches.
It looks less like a purpose-built concert hall and more like an airport hangar.
I couldn't help wondering whether somebody originally intended to fill the place with three floors of slot machines before deciding, at the last minute, “Ah, screw it. We need a theatre. Fuck the acoustics.”
I'm kidding, of course.
At least I hope I am.
With no obvious acoustic treatment to tame the reflections, the sound seemed to bounce around the room, swallowing instrumental detail and turning intricate passages into a wash of reverberation.
Even Belew's between-song remarks were difficult to understand. I caught a few words here and there and reconstructed the rest from context.
It's a shame live concerts don't come with subtitles.
And the problems weren't limited to what we could hear.
The seating was arranged on a completely flat floor, without the gradual rise known as raked seating.
I was in row seventeen, directly in front of Steve Vai. Unfortunately, the three gentlemen occupying the aisle seats in the rows immediately ahead of me were all taller than I am. And I'm six-foot-one, for crying out loud. Thankfully, we all had aisle seats.
So we spent much of the evening leaning in the opposite direction of whoever was sitting immediately ahead of us, hoping the person in front of him wasn't doing exactly the same thing.
It was less like watching a concert and more like participating in a particularly uncooperative game of human Tetris.
For a band whose music depends on extraordinary precision, the venue did the performers and audience few favours.
The Bozzio FactorOf the four musicians, Terry Bozzio was perhaps the one I was most curious to hear.
I'd seen BEAT with Danny Carey behind the drums last year, and the opportunity to hear Bozzio's interpretation of the same material was enormously appealing.
Bozzio's drum kit is something of a legend in itself.
Even the relatively modest configuration he sometimes refers to as his “jazz kit” would probably require its own building permit in most drummers' homes.
Unfortunately, the room's acoustics affected his playing more than anyone else's.
For much of the evening, with all four musicians playing, Bozzio's extraordinarily intricate drumming was reduced to the larger accents: kick drums, snare hits and cymbal crashes.
The rapid-fire details between them were swallowed by the room.
The sound engineer appeared to spend much of the night fighting to get the drums under control. As the evening progressed, more of Bozzio's playing began to emerge, although at least one kick drum became increasingly prominent, occasionally threatening to overwhelm everything else.
I don't think Bozzio suddenly started playing better toward the end.
I think we were finally beginning to hear more of what he'd been doing all along.
After the twenty-minute intermission, Bozzio began “Waiting Man” alone at the front of the stage, with Belew eventually joining him on percussion before the rest of the band entered.
Later, leading into “Indiscipline,” Belew and Vai laid out while Levin maintained a subtle rhythmic pulse, true to the original arrangement.
Bozzio was effectively given the floor.
And suddenly, we could hear him.
All of him.
The intricate figures, the rapid interplay across that enormous kit, the details that had been disappearing into the mix all evening.
It was glorious.
And more than a little frustrating, because it demonstrated just how much we'd been missing.
I've seen Terry Bozzio enough times to know what an extraordinary musician he is. I have little doubt he was delivering that level of performance throughout the evening.
I just wish we'd been able to hear it.
A Little Humour, and a Lot of HeartBelew has always had a wonderfully mischievous stage presence.
Before the intermission, he'd encouraged everyone to go and have a drink. Then, following “Waiting Man,” he addressed the audience again.
“So how many T-shirts did we buy? Or, I mean, how many drinks did we all have?”
The crowd laughed.
And yes, I actually managed to hear that one.
But the evening wasn't all rhythmic gymnastics and instrumental fireworks.
There was also “Matte Kudasai.”
I've always considered it one of the most beautiful songs ever written. Period.
Amid all the complexity and guitar pyrotechnics, it offered a few minutes of something entirely different.
Calm. Warmth. That familiar feeling of hearing a piece of music you've loved for decades and discovering that it still makes you feel just as good as it always has.
Some songs don't need to knock you out of your seat to leave an impression.
“Matte Kudasai” has always been one of those songs for me.
The Audience and the EncoreThe audience itself was an entertaining cross-section of musical obsessives.
There were the expected middle-aged and older eccentrics, some looking suspiciously like wizards, others like people who spent their spare time researching how to become one. There were younger rock fans, King Crimson shirts, Zappa shirts and even a scattering of death-metal T-shirts.
I was wearing a Zappa shirt myself, although mine was a little unusual. It was made exclusively for backers of Alex Winter's documentary Zappa. I helped fund the film and even managed to get my name into the credits.
Yes, I'm in the credits of a Frank Zappa documentary. Allow me this one small moment of self-importance.🤣
For the encore, BEAT reached into the Frank Zappa catalogue with “City of Tiny Lites.”
I have to admit, I was a little underwhelmed by the choice. I'd already seen clips of the band performing it on this tour, so there wasn't much element of surprise.
But hearing it was heartwarming nonetheless.
Belew sang the song on Zappa's Sheik Yerbouti, with Bozzio on drums. Vai, of course, would later become part of Zappa's musical world as well.
Three former Zappa musicians sharing the stage again, performing music from that extraordinary catalogue.
That's a pretty special thing for a Zappa fanatic to witness.
I only wish I'd been able to understand Belew's introduction. I caught Zappa's name and what sounded like a joking acknowledgement that three of the four musicians had played with him — “not you, Tony” — but the rest disappeared into the room's echo.
During the song, Vai used his guitar to recreate the keyboard and piano parts, coaxing remarkably convincing sounds out of the instrument before switching back to a more conventional guitar tone for his solo.
Apparently, being Steve Vai wasn't quite enough. He had to be the keyboard player, too.
Unfortunately, by the encore, a contingent of audience members had abandoned their seats and rushed the stage, effectively eliminating what little view some of us had managed to negotiate.
The evening concluded with “Thela Hun Ginjeet,” and somewhere during the song I spotted an old acquaintance known to many Toronto concertgoers as Grateful Dave.
Dave is an old Deadhead who dances at absolutely everything, including music that most people would struggle to tap a foot to.
And there he was again, dancing to King Crimson, although the cramped seating had reduced his usual free-ranging movements to something resembling a Deadhead dancing in captivity.
I couldn't resist recording a short clip for friends who know him.
Some people find his dancing distracting. I've always found his enthusiasm infectious.
Why I Go to ConcertsAbout halfway through the first set, I took out my phone and typed something into my notes.
Not a song title.
Not a technical observation.
Just a thought that had been running through my head as I watched these four musicians.
Nights out like this are why I work. To be able to go out and experience something like this. To witness true masters of their craft.
I've spent much of my life listening to these musicians, sometimes studying what they do, sometimes simply enjoying the extraordinary music they've helped create.
They've all influenced the way I hear music.
And here I was, watching them together.
Not performing a museum-piece recreation of King Crimson's catalogue, but treating those compositions as living music, something worth exploring and occasionally challenging.
The sound wasn't perfect. In fact, it was a genuine disappointment where Bozzio's drums were concerned. The sightlines weren't much better.
But the musicianship?
Extraordinary.
Walking through the lobby afterward, I turned to my friends and said, “This is why I work. This is why I earn money. For nights like THIS. To witness what we just saw.”
And I meant every word.
The theatre had done the musicians few favours, but it hadn't diminished the awe I felt at what we'd just witnessed.
Four musicians I've admired for decades, each bringing his own personality to music that has meant a great deal to me.
And somehow finding room for all four personalities in the same compositions.
There are worse reasons to get up and go to work.
And considerably worse ways to spend a Sunday night.