Alan Cross: Reviewing the Reviewer
Photo: Photo courtesy of FirstOntario Performing Arts Centre

Alan Cross: Reviewing the Reviewer

An evening of music-industry secrets, fascinating stories and one reviewer wishing he had a pause button.

By David Horhota · Published November 15, 2026 · Alan Cross · FirstOntario Performing Arts Centre (opens venue website in a new tab) · November 14, 2026

How does one review a reviewer?

I've been asking myself that question since I first considered attending Alan Cross's presentation at the FirstOntario Performing Arts Centre.

In fact, I wasn't entirely convinced I should attempt a review at all.

Cross has spent decades working in music broadcasting and journalism, much of that time researching and telling stories about the music industry. He's probably forgotten more about the business than most of us will ever know.

And here I was, contemplating writing a review of him.

Well, all right then.

Saturday evening, I found myself in the Recital Hall, listening to one of Canada's best-known music historians explain some of the decidedly less respectable aspects of the industry.

Organized crime, payola, corruption and the questionable dealings that have taken place behind the scenes of the music business.

Fascinating stuff.

Cross is an extraordinarily knowledgeable man, and the amount of research behind his presentation was impressive. But as the stories kept coming, I found myself wishing he'd slow down.

I wanted a pause button.

There was so much information coming at us that I barely had time to absorb one revelation before he was introducing another.

At times, it felt like listening to someone read a particularly interesting book aloud, only to turn the page before I'd finished thinking about what was on it.

And I really wanted to read that book.

Not because I was bored. Quite the opposite.

The presentation was clearly well rehearsed, with occasional questions directed toward the audience that sometimes felt as though they were part of the script rather than genuine attempts at conversation.

Then something happened that felt entirely spontaneous.

Cross paused and reflected on his many years working in radio, including several stints as a program director.

Despite all the stories he'd just been telling us about payola and corruption, he joked that in all those years, nobody had ever thought to offer him a bribe.

Not once.

He seemed genuinely amused by the oversight.

And so was I.

It was a wonderfully funny moment, made even better because it seemed to emerge naturally rather than from the prepared material.

I would have enjoyed a few more moments like that.

Following a twenty-minute intermission, Cross returned to answer questions from the audience about practically anything related to the music industry.

This was the part I'd been looking forward to.

And it didn't disappoint.

The atmosphere was more relaxed, and Cross was clearly in his element, responding with lengthy, entertaining stories drawn from his years in the business.

There was one small problem.

Unless you happened to be sitting near the person asking a question, you probably couldn't hear it.

At least I couldn't.

Fortunately, Cross rarely gives a short answer. His responses were detailed enough that you could usually work out what the question must have been.

And even when you couldn't, you still got a good story out of it.

That's not a bad arrangement.

I particularly enjoyed this more conversational side of Cross. Without the constraints of the prepared presentation, his humour and personality had more room to emerge.

So, how does one review a reviewer?

Apparently, much the same way one reviews anyone else who steps onto a stage.

And by that measure, Alan Cross delivered a fascinating and thoroughly worthwhile evening.

He's a brilliant, remarkably knowledgeable and frequently funny storyteller with an extraordinary collection of music-industry history at his disposal.

I'm not going to attempt to reproduce all those stories here. For one thing, I couldn't possibly do them justice from memory. And for another, you really should hear him tell them himself.

If you get the opportunity to see one of his presentations, I'd recommend it.

And if you don't, there's always The Ongoing History of New Music, his long-running syndicated radio programme, along with an extensive archive of free podcasts.

Plenty of opportunities to hear more of those stories.

With one distinct advantage.

You can pause a podcast.

Or rewind it.

And take a little time to absorb what you've just heard.

I rather like that idea.


Afterward, we headed over to Helliwell Hall to catch JIN for one set.

One set. One pint.

I had a new car to drive home, after all.

And JIN killed, as always.

No, I'm not writing another review.

Some evenings, I'm allowed to just enjoy the music.